las

Welcome all seeking refuge from low carb dogma!

“To kill an error is as good a service as, and sometimes even better than, the establishing of a new truth or fact”
~ Charles Darwin (it's evolutionary baybeee!)

Sunday, February 23, 2014

The Optimal Diet for Type 2 Diabetes

Now that I have your attention ...

Guess what?  There is no single optimal diet to treat/manage the disease.  I don't often do short bookmarking posts here much anymore, but I thought this paper that I found down a PubMed rabbit hole the other day was worthy of more than just a link in the library.  

Most importantly there is evidence that adherence to any given dietary approach is more important than the macronutrient prescription. So the best diet for those with type 2 diabetes is the one that works for them, and critically the one that they can maintain in the long term.
How many times, tucked somewhere in the discussion of the latest diet comparison clinical trial, or mumbled by the researcher in the press conference, have we heard that in the end, adherence was the single best predictor of whatever-the-heck-health-weight-measure-improvements regardless of assigned intervention.


There's nothing super ground breaking in this article, but I think it's worth a read.  Ultimately, diabetes is a disease of relative insulin deficiency and excessive endogenous glucose production.  Unless your diet changes pancreatic function for the better, and it's a diet you can live with, you may well end up worse off than if you did nothing at all.  (Note the use of the word may). 

One other comment if I may here, and that is in regards to labeling your diet.  I understand this, been there, done that.  But with all of this redefining going on with paleo to where paleos are eating anything and anything you eat can make you paleo, it's time to perhaps pick some of the better strategies from various approaches and apply them to yourself.  Protein satiates?  There's no reason a high protein diet has to be low carb or high fat, it can just as easily be the opposite.  Olive oil does good things?  Anyone can eat olive oil, even someone on a "low fat" diet.  Ditto avocados.  There's nothing about the avocado that makes it off limits on any diet.  There's also no need to be all-or-nothing.  Take dairy.  If you tolerate it, you can eat it, but if you like a glass of milk have one, or drink some each day or drink it on Sundays.  There's no need to impose rules because you are doing some detox or have "started XYZ diet".  

8 comments:

charles grashow said...

http://kidneylifescience.ca/dr-jason-fung/insulin-causes-insulin-resistance-hormonal-obesity-x/

"The longer and higher the insulin levels, the higher the insulin resistance. The higher the resistance, the higher the insulin. This is what sets into motion the time dependent effects of obesity. The fat get fatter. The longer you have obesity, the harder it is to eradicate. Insulin Causes Obesity.

Everybody knows about these time dependent effects. However, most current thinking about obesity completely ignores these effects even though they are plainly obvious to anybody and everybody. Since type 2 Diabetes is all about insulin resistance – this also leads us to the inescapable conclusion that Insulin Causes Diabetes.

Insulin causes both obesity and diabetes. This is the new science of Diabesity. With this new understanding, we are led to entirely new possibilities for the cure of diabesity. If high insulin levels are thecause, then the cure is to lower insulin levels. Cure type 2 diabetes?
Can it be true? Yes, but we still have some work before we get there.

To be continued…"

eulerandothers said...

Avocados? Dairy? You mean we can eat anything?
Sounds like Weight Watchers to me.
Dangerous stuff.

carbsane said...

I'm waiting for Nutrisystem Paleo ;-)

carbsane said...

This one is very deep down the TWICHOO rabbit hole. I guess he doesn't realize that lowering insulin has had nominal to no effect on weight in studies. So little, Lustig abandoned it and his attempts to patent it for sugar-fear mongering.

charles grashow said...

More WOO WOO

http://rosemarycottageclinic.wordpress.com/2014/02/25/is-low-carb-really-normo-carb/

About
Hello, I am Afifah Hamilton, a Medical Herbalist, Nutritionist, GAPS
Practitioner, Counsellor and Massage Therapist living near Chichester,
West Sussex, UK.

My area of specialist research is metabolism and the ketogenic diet,
particularly its application to neurological, hormonal, cardiovascular,
malignant, auto-immune and diabetic conditions.

t s said...

Well, I say, "Pass me the rice and beans, now".......

http://www.businessinsider.com/test-predicts-if-you-will-die-in-five-years-2014-2

charles grashow said...

http://suppversity.blogspot.com/2014/03/losing-weight-doesnt-have-to-ruin-your.html

http://www.caseperformance.com/142/interview-with-the-expert-adel-moussa-part-i

charles grashow said...

http://www.caseperformance.com/216/creatine-beyond-brawn-part-i-diabetes-and-glycemic-control

Post a Comment

Moderation is currently on. Thanks in advance for your patience.